Behind the Evil Eyes: The (Real) Story of the Amityville House

The notorious Long Island house will forever be associated with its dark, overly publicized past, but does it really deserve its reputation?

amityville house at 112 Ocean Drive long island

  • 4
    Shares

There are some U.S. addresses that can conjure up spine-tingling fear with each mention. Think 10050 Cielo Drive in California, 333 East Wonderview Avenue in Colorado, 5481 County Road in Wisconsin, 611 Oak Avenue in Kansas, and last but not least, 112 Ocean Avenue in New York. While the events that took place at famous properties like the Stanley Hotel are purely fictitious, others have a very real history of darkness. 

Such is the case of the infamous 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island. The otherwise charming mansion will sadly forever be associated with the gruesome crimes that took place here in the 1970s, and the alleged supernatural events that followed soon after.

Nevertheless, the ‘house with the evil eyes’ now has new owners, and they are reportedly undeterred by all the dark tales and hype surrounding their new home. The hype, however, continues, with the latest (and 16th) Amityville-related movie launched just two years ago. So what is it about this house that, 45 years later after it entered our radars, still holds such a fascination?

SEE ALSO: How the Sharon Tate Murder House on Cielo Drive Shed Its Sordid Past — Movie Tie-in with Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood”

The Beginning

The history of the house at 112 Ocean Avenue begins in 1927 in the small, quaint town of Amityville, roughly 30 miles outside New York City.

John and Catherine Moynahan started building their dream home here in 1924, and they lived in the house happily for many years. Then, in 1965, their descendants sold the home to the DeFeos, a seemingly happy and well-off family with Italian roots, who left Brooklyn for Long Island. This is when things started to fall apart for the Amityville house. 

112 Ocean Avenue, courtesy of Flickr user Candace Carrillo (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

The DeFeo family had 7 members: Ronald DeFeo Sr., his wife Louise, and their children, 23-year-old Ronald “Butch” DeFeo Jr., 18-year-old Dawn, 13-year-old Allison, 12-year-old Marc, and 9-year-old John Matthew. The eldest son, Ronald, or Ronnie, as friends called him, was a troubled young man who wasn’t able to find his place in the world, who couldn’t hold down a job, and who was in constant fights with his father. 

At 3.15 AM on the night of November 13th, 1974, Ronnie, for reasons we’re not sure of even today, grabbed a shotgun and proceeded to kill his entire family in just 15 minutes. He shot each family member point blank, then took a shower and went out to town claiming that someone had broken into his house and killed his family. Yet his story didn’t take long to unravel, and he soon confessed to being the sole perpetrator to the authorities. He was tried in court and received several consecutive life sentences; he is still serving time in prison today. 

Over the years, Ronnie DeFeo changed his story various times. Once, he claimed that his sister Dawn killed the family members; another time he claimed that a stranger broke into the house, killed his entire family, then left; and the most puzzling story of all was that he was guided by dark voices, and that the house told him to do it. Whatever the truth was, there was no going back: the Amityville mansion was now a notorious murder house. 

Obviously, finding new owners for the house at 112 Ocean Avenue was no easy task, yet somehow, the house once again became a home less than a year after the murders. The low asking price of $80,000 certainly helped, and George and Kathy Lutz soon moved into their new home. 

amityville house aerial view
Aerial view of the Amityville house in Long Island

Second Life

George and Kathy Lutz didn’t really get to enjoy life in their new mansion for long. They followed the advice of a friend and had the house ‘cleansed’ by a priest before moving in, but as it turned out, that didn’t help much. 

There’s no way of knowing if what the Lutzes claimed actually happened, but one thing is clear: they got out of that house as fast as humanly possible, and they never even came back to get any of their things. What’s more, they were so freaked out that they left the coast and moved all the way out to California. But what the hell happened?

The couple claimed that soon after they moved into the Amityville house, strange things started happening, and they got increasingly creepier as the days went by. George Lutz started hearing voices, random knocking noises, doors would allegedly slam on their own, and other creepy stuff like that. Kathy Lutz also said that she discovered a secret room that wasn’t in the original house plans, and that this room was painted red — blood red. 

SEE ALSO: Owners of House that Inspired ‘The Conjuring’ Say It’s Haunted, Plan to Open It to the Public

It all finally became too much when the walls supposedly started oozing some kind of slimy green yucky stuff, and the Lutzes decided it was time to get out.

Just 28 days after they moved to Amityville, they left the house, but insisted that they didn’t plan for it to be their last night there. What they said is that whatever dark forces were in the house, they followed them that night; they never went into detail about what happened, but they never returned to 112 Ocean Avenue either. George and Kathy left all of their belongings there and put the house back on the market. 

However, the Lutzes didn’t exactly leave quietly. They were quite outspoken and upfront about what they were experiencing at the house, and they got other people interested, too. Things looked pretty serious when famed paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren got involved (you know them from The Conjuring movies). The Lutzes both took lie detector tests and passed with flying colors. But many were skeptical about their story, and thought they were just looking for exposure and to make some money off of their experience. 

The ‘paranormal’ phenomena experienced by George and Kathy Lutz served as inspiration for Jay Anson’s 1977 book, The Amityville Horror, as well as for the original 1979 movie and the 2005 remake (you’ve seen it, Ryan Reynolds stars as Ronnie DeFeo). Numerous other films, documentaries and books were created about the Amityville house, and that’s why all future owners of the property had trouble keeping people away. 

Third Time’s the Charm?

Many previous owners of the Amityville house had to move out over the years, fed up with the attention their home was attracting on a daily basis. TIME Magazine even included the house on their list of the top 10 haunted places in America, which certainly didn’t help anyone forget about all that happened.

And yet nobody else ever complained about strange, paranormal happenings at 112 Ocean Avenue. Which makes one wonder if George and Kathy Lutz truly did just take advantage of the events surrounding their new house. 

Caroline and David D’Antonio purchased the property in 2010 for $950,000, and embarked on a major renovation effort. The home, now with a new address of 108 Ocean Avenue, features 5,000 square feet of living space and amenities like a modern kitchen, a redesigned basement, high-end security systems, a large boat house, swimming pool, and a two-car garage.

112 Ocean Avenue waterfront, courtesy of Flickr user stretchdog
(CC BY-NC 2.0)

The owners repainted the house, but kept original touches like the leaded glass and oak floors. The ‘evil eyes’ of the home, which is how people used to refer to the two attic windows, were also redone to tone down the evil — a bit late for that, but things were starting to look positive for the infamous murder house. 

Closure

In the summer of 2016, the house was put up for sale once again, after the untimely passing of David D’Antonio. It hit the market with an asking price of $850,000, and eventually sold in February 2017, though well below ask, at $605,000. 

It’s all been quiet on the Amityville front since the new owners entered the picture, which we think is a good sign that the house might be shedding its dark past at last. However, our fascination for the paranormal and haunted houses is as strong as ever, and we’re pretty sure that more movies and stories based on the Amityville events will continue to pop up. 

What do you think, is the house haunted or not? Did the Lutzes make it all up, or did the house just…not like them? Let us know your thoughts!

Leading image credit: BrownieCharles99 [CC BY-SA 3.0]

More spooky homes

Owners of House that Inspired ‘The Conjuring’ Say It’s Haunted, Plan to Open It to the Public
Zooming In on the Stanley Hotel, Stephen King’s Inspiration for ‘The Shining’
The Winchester House — The Haunted Mansion that Inspired the Name of Supernatural’s Winchester Brothers
Darkness Into Light: How the Sharon Tate Murder House on Cielo Drive Shed Its Sordid Past


  • 4
    Shares

Written by Ioana Neamt

Experienced writer with a background in real estate and a fondness for soaring skyscrapers and Victorian-style mansions. Also loves fancy homes with crackling fireplaces and views of snowy mountains.

2 Comments

Leave a Reply
  1. However, when it came time to review the film, Ebert didn’t concern himself so much with whether Lutz was telling the truth or not. He was more concerned with how entertaining the story would read on screen. “Was he telling the truth? Did green slime really squirt from the keyholes? Did a red-eyed pig really glare through the windows? Did a ghostly marching band really parade through the living room? Maybe so; we’ve all made bad real estate investments. But the question isn’t so much whether those terrible things really happened as whether (please forgive me for my lack of reverence) they’ve been made into an entertaining movie. They have not.” Guess Ebert wasn t a fan.

  2. films is the distinctive pumpkin head appearance of the house, which was created by two quarter round windows on the third floor attic level. The windows are often illuminated in the films, giving the appearance of malevolent eyes. The first three films were filmed at a house in Toms River, New Jersey which had been converted to look like 112 Ocean Avenue after the authorities in Amityville denied permission for location filming. Although not all of the films in

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *