Long before the Kennedys became synonymous with Hyannis Port, Georgetown, Palm Beach, and Manhattan’s Upper East Side, the family’s New York roots were firmly planted in Riverdale.
Now, one of the Bronx’s most intriguing estates is back on the market with a $500,000 price reduction.
Listed for $5.85 million by Dustin Crouse and Erin Boisson Aries of Douglas Elliman, the sprawling property at 5040 Independence Avenue sits on the very site where John F. Kennedy’s childhood home once stood — a remarkable piece of presidential history that has since been transformed into a grand contemporary mansion.
The site of JFK’s childhood home
It was here that Joseph and Rose Kennedy settled their growing family after relocating from Boston to New York in the 1920s.
The move brought Joseph Kennedy closer to the worlds of finance and entertainment while placing young Jack within walking distance of Riverdale Country School, where he attended classes before the family eventually returned to Massachusetts.
What remains of the original Kennedy house
The original Kennedy residence, built in 1907, remained on the property for decades.
After the family sold it in 1959, subsequent owners altered the home before it was ultimately demolished sometime after 1991.
According to the listing agents, remnants of the original foundation wall still survive within the basement of today’s residence, providing one of the few physical links to the home where the future president once lived.
The estate that replaced it is dramatically different in both scale and ambition.
A mansion inspired by the Guggenheim
Occupying more than 1.2 acres overlooking the renowned Wave Hill gardens and the Hudson River Valley, the primary mansion spans approximately 17,620 square feet across three levels, with an additional 7,500-square-foot basement awaiting completion and customization.
The property also includes a separate 2,000-square-foot cottage with three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and an attached two-car garage, making it well suited for guests, staff, or extended family.
Architecturally, the residence takes inspiration from one of New York City’s most recognizable landmarks: Frank Lloyd Wright’s Guggenheim Museum.
At its center is a spectacular triple-height atrium whose sweeping curves and rotunda-like form flood the home with natural light while creating an unforgettable arrival experience.
Designed for grand-scale living
The mansion offers nine bedrooms, seven full bathrooms, and two powder rooms, with generously proportioned living spaces designed for large-scale entertaining.
A dramatic sunken living room opens onto expansive terraces overlooking the Hudson Valley, while a formal dining room, multiple entertaining salons, a media room, library, and spacious eat-in kitchen with its own morning terrace complete the main living areas.
Altogether, the estate features approximately 4,500 square feet of terraced outdoor space that takes full advantage of its elevated setting above Wave Hill.
A 10-car garage further reinforces the property’s rare combination of privacy, scale, and flexibility — qualities seldom found this close to Manhattan.
A rare opportunity to complete the vision
Although substantial work has been completed over several decades, the residence remains an unfinished vision.
The current owners have continued developing the property through multiple phases since acquiring it in 1991, with the most recent work completed within the past decade.
The home will be delivered with a Temporary Certificate of Occupancy, giving its next owner the opportunity to complete the estate according to their own vision.
Properties associated with the Kennedy family regularly attract attention, but few offer such a direct connection to the beginning of the dynasty’s story.
While the original house is gone, the address remains the place where one of America’s most famous political families established its New York home — and where a young John F. Kennedy spent part of the childhood that preceded one of the most consequential lives in American history.
More stories
Frank Sinatra’s iconic family brownstone in Hoboken, New Jersey hits the market for $3.95M
One of Brooklyn’s most significant Queen Anne homes hits the market for $3.845M
The Office’s Rainn Wilson pays tribute to his humble childhood home
