In the Hamptons, the house can change. Four acres of waterfront land is considerably harder to replace.
That is the real draw at 41 Niamogue Lane, a newly listed Quogue estate asking $11.9 million.
Spread across four private acres, the property combines direct waterfront access with mature grounds, broad water views and a substantial mid-century home that has been expanded over time rather than replaced with the modern farmhouse architecture now common across the East End.
The approximately 7,500-square-foot residence has six bedrooms, seven full bathrooms and two half-baths, along with a saltwater gunite pool, separate pool house and direct access to the water for kayaking, paddleboarding and fishing.
Susan Orioli and James Orioli of Engel & Völkers North Fork hold the listing.
The property is being offered for sale for the first time by only its second owner, another indication of how tightly held this stretch of Quogue has been.
And while the existing house carries plenty of architectural interest, the acreage immediately sets the offering apart.
Four contiguous waterfront acres provide far more breathing room than most newly built Hamptons properties, allowing the house to sit within broad lawns and mature landscaping rather than dominating the site.
That privacy is enhanced by the estate’s position within an established Quogue enclave, while the village and ocean beaches remain nearby.
The residence itself dates to the mid-century era and has been enlarged over the years, creating an architectural mix that feels considerably more individual than a freshly built speculative home.
A traditional gambrel roof gives the exterior a familiar Hamptons profile, while inside, French-country influences and mid-century details appear through arched openings, brick flooring and a curved stucco staircase with brick treads.
Substantial hand-carved paneled doors add another layer of texture.
The grand living room has coffered ceilings and a wood-burning fireplace, while a second fireplace anchors the great room.
Those spaces are lined with expansive custom windows and doors, bringing natural light deep inside while keeping the surrounding lawns and water visible from the interiors.
The bedroom arrangement makes the house particularly flexible for extended families.
There are primary suites on both the first and second floors, allowing owners to choose between one-level living and a more traditional upstairs retreat.
Each of the remaining bedrooms is also en suite, giving guests their own private bathroom rather than requiring shared accommodations.
Outside, the saltwater gunite pool becomes the centerpiece of the warmer months.
A separate pool house includes a half-bath, while broad lawns provide plenty of space around the swimming area for lounging and entertaining without crowding the main residence.
Beyond the pool, the property continues toward the waterfront.
Private access makes it possible to launch kayaks or paddleboards directly from the grounds, while fishing and birdwatching provide a quieter alternative to the more social side of Hamptons summer life.
For larger boats and sailing, Shinnecock Yacht Club is also close by.
The current owners have made several significant updates in recent years.
A cedar-shingle roof was installed in 2023, while whole-house central air followed in 2024. The property also has newer windows, a new irrigation system, generator and Level 2 EV charger.
Those improvements leave the home with its established architectural character while addressing many of the systems expected in a modern year-round residence.
At $11.9 million, the estate ranks among Quogue’s higher-priced current offerings.
But the listing’s strongest argument isn’t necessarily the square footage or even the house itself.
It’s the combination of four waterfront acres, privacy and an established residence in a market where large parcels close to the water have become increasingly difficult to find.
The architecture can evolve again if a future owner chooses.
The land is the part that cannot be recreated.
More stories
The ultimate Hamptons staycation starts at this newly-listed $6.5M estate
Acclaimed Vanity Fair photographer lists meticulously restored 1882 Victorian in Sag Harbor
