A rare gem has surfaced on one of the most sought-after blocks in Manhattan’s West Village.
Known as The Heroy House, this grand five-story townhouse just hit the market with a $17.5 million asking price — and it’s the kind of listing that’s commands our attention with both its past (we’ll get to that in a sec) and potential for the future.
Listed by Denver Butson of Douglas Elliman, the townhouse has 8 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, 2 half-baths, and multiple outdoor spaces, including a private garden and rooftop terrace, just steps from the heart of downtown New York.
Like Fancy Pants Homes’ content? Be sure to follow us on MSN
Pre-war elegance at 262 West 11th Street
Built in 1828 by master sash maker Lavinius C. Heroy, the namesake residence at 262 West 11th Street is steeped in history, but also remarkably adaptable.
Offering over 5,000 square feet of interior space and set on a coveted 21-foot-wide lot, the home is a prime example of pre-war elegance that’s ready for a next-generation makeover. High ceilings, sun-filled rooms, and preserved period details make it a standout in a neighborhood already known for its charm.
Over 5,000 square feet of historic West Village living
The Heroy House isn’t your typical Manhattan townhouse. Unlike narrow row homes that line the West Village, this semi-detached property stretches across 21 feet of width and boasts exposures on 3 sides — 4 on one level — flooding the interiors with natural light.
A skylight above the central staircase only adds to the home’s airy feel, especially on the top two floors.
Built in 1928 by a master craftsman
The home’s origin story dates back nearly two centuries. Lavinius C. Heroy, a master sash maker, built the townhouse for his own use in 1828, and his craftsmanship still shows.
Signature features like the ornate window lintels, original archways, and floor-to-ceiling parlor windows have stood the test of time and continue to lend authenticity to the home’s classic facade and interiors.
Original details add character and warmth
Inside, The Heroy House is filled with irreplaceable prewar details that give the space soul. Think wide-plank hardwood floors, exposed beams and brick, oversized parlor windows with period moldings, original shutters, and elegant archways.
The high ceilings on every level only add to the home’s sense of vertical scale and grandeur.
Eight bedrooms and endless flexibility
With 8 bedrooms spread throughout 5 floors, The Heroy House is designed to flex with a wide range of modern living needs.
Whether reimagined as a single-family showpiece or thoughtfully reconfigured to incorporate guest suites, home offices, or creative studios, the home offers ample room to tailor each floor to a unique lifestyle vision.
Outdoor space on every level
The home’s outdoor offerings are impressive by any standard, especially in a neighborhood where green space is at a premium.
A south-facing patio and meditative garden anchor the backyard, while a private roof terrace is located directly off the primary bedroom. There’s also the potential to add a full rooftop terrace and balconies on the middle floors — subject to approvals — offering a rare opportunity to expand both square footage and skyline views.
A rare West Village horse walk
One of the most unique aspects of the property is the inclusion of a horse walk — a private alleyway that runs alongside the home and leads directly to the south-facing garden.
Once used for stabling horses, this rare architectural element now serves as a discreet and charming passage to the rear outdoor space, adding to the home’s character.
A distinguished address on a landmark block
Located on one of the West Village’s most iconic blocks, the townhouse comes with a heritage address. The surrounding streets are lined with leafy trees, landmarked facades, and some of the most desirable real estate in New York City.
From chic boutiques to neighborhood cafés, everything West Village residents love is just steps away.
On the market for $17.5 million
Listed at $17.5 million and represented by Denver Butson and Maria Saha of Douglas Elliman, The Heroy House is one of the few remaining properties that blends historic authenticity with modern potential.
Showings are by appointment only — and for those looking to write their own chapter in West Village history, the opportunity is now.
More stories
5-Story West Village townhouse reflects the history-rich character of Commerce Street
The Upper East Side’s “first modern townhouse” is up for grabs
